Separate health issues?

I think it's safe to say that you have failed to achieve consensus on this issue, by any definition of it.

Philippe, will you agree to a public debate to resolve this impasse?

No. There is no impasse, James, only you trying to advance a position when you've failed to find a single person to support your position.

This is ~my~ last comment on this. I won't be drawn into your antagonistic games. You won't succeed in needling or pushing me into further comment.

And unless you generate consensus, your position will remain the minority position, and not the consensus position.

Here endeth the statement by me.