Jump to content

English wiki Unsourced BLP Drama Pragmatic Review

Fragment of a discussion from Village pump/en

I waited a bit for the fellow-up.

Things split into 3 discussions:

  1. Fist RFC talk page
  2. Second RFC aka Round 2
  3. Spin-out RFC on content of BLP article

Discussion 1 is still discussing the relevance of whole process and again arguing on the flawed premises of the RFC.

Discussion 2 is the real negotiation. Number of actives negotiators and onlookers dropped drastically because it has become more technical, people left the matter to the de-facto "representatives" of their views and projects (minus the BLP project) don't feel anymore the need to press for a compromise as their own clean-up processes are under way.

Discussion 3 is somewhat a stalemate and will probably remain so because it's too much related to the current unsourced BLP negotiation for either party to try a significant move here because of the risk of duplicity accusation. Giving from one hand "Discussion 2" while taking from the other "Discussion 3".

KrebMarkt‎21:01, 11 February 2010
Retrieved from "https://strategy.wikimedia.org/wiki/Thread:Village_pump/en/English_wiki_Unsourced_BLP_Drama_Pragmatic_Review/reply_(13)"